P2PU Open Source Developer
Submission

Dirk

I learned how Lernanta works and also how to use git through github!

Link to work submitted

Progress:

Received 3 reviews of the 2 reviews needed.
The posted reviews give this work submission a total average score of 3.00 (needs to be at least 3 for the badge to be awarded).

Reviews

Assessment from Jos on May 10, 2012, 7:28 a.m.
1. Did the change address a specific bug/feature?
  
  4 out of 4
  
  Always
2. Did the change effectively fix/implement the bug/feature?
  
  4 out of 4
  
  Always
3. Is the final change merged into Lernanta and used at p2pu.org?
  
  4 out of 4
  
  Always
- Final rating
  
  4.0 out of 4
  
  Always
Comment:

The fix involved several different parts of the application, fixing a bug and adding content, and more than one interaction with git, so all the reqs have been fulfilled.
Assessment from Zuzel Vera on May 11, 2012, 7:58 a.m.
1. Did the change address a specific bug/feature?
  
  4 out of 4
  
  Always
2. Did the change effectively fix/implement the bug/feature?
  
  4 out of 4
  
  Always
3. Is the final change merged into Lernanta and used at p2pu.org?
  
  4 out of 4
  
  Always
- Final rating
  
  4.0 out of 4
  
  Always
Comment:

Nice work!
Assessment from Buzzy on May 15, 2012, 3:47 p.m.
1. Did the change address a specific bug/feature?
  
  1 out of 4
  
  Never
2. Did the change effectively fix/implement the bug/feature?
  
  1 out of 4
  
  Never
3. Is the final change merged into Lernanta and used at p2pu.org?
  
  1 out of 4
  
  Never
- Final rating
  
  1.0 out of 4
  
  Never
Comment:

I can't tell. Dirk appears to know what he's doing but I see no evidence of the task requirements and in fact, from what I can understand of the changes, they're not merged and in use here. Needs explanation and evidence that the requirements have been met. Sorry.